I had mixed reactions to the
readings. The Johnson article on
patriarchy was very interesting, and really made me think about the way our
society is organized. In the
beginning part of the chapter, Johnson attempted to liken underlying nature of
a patriarchy to the fact that American culture is based on the idea of
capitalism. I disagree with the
comparison, but I understand his point.
However, later in the article, he begins talking about how “patriarchal
culture is about the core value of control and domination in almost every area
of human existence.” He believes
that the concepts of power and control come from patriarchy. I would argue that these two concepts are
part of being human, and that they do not derive their meanings from
patriarchies. I have a hard time
believing that before the existence of a patriarchy, humans had no idea to have
power and control. Going back to
the earliest humans, the idea of power almost has to be innate, to support
survival. Johnson almost seems to
suggest that without a patriarchy, humans would either not have concepts for
power and control, or that they would be very different concepts. I understand that power and control are
crucial elements of a patriarchy, and that they are perhaps abused as a part of
the system, but I take issue with the idea that two concepts so central to our
culture are rooted in the concept of a patriarchy.
I enjoyed the second article until Frye chose opening a door for a woman as
something to take issue with. The
way I was raised, it is both polite and appreciated to open a door for a woman. I have done it ever since I was
little. In my family, it’s even
normal for my dad to walk to the passenger side of the car to open the door for
my mother. Obviously she is more
than capable of doing it for herself, but it’s a kind gesture that is
appreciated. I find it hard to
believe that some women are offended by someone opening the door for them, and
I also disagree with the idea that it is any way designed as a debilitating or
negative action towards women. I hold the door for men as well, simply because
it’s a kind thing to do and is appreciated by everyone. Manners do have a place in society, and
this is simply one example.
No comments:
Post a Comment